marmasatt
USER INFORMATION
- Feedback Requests
-
0
- Lifetime Donations
-
$1
- HeatWare Rank
-
#411 of 87,580 users
Verified Identities
Community Aliases (Unverified)
-
SamirD (57)
I sold Samir a box full of SAS drives and 25 sticks of DDR/DDR2/DDR3. I consider it almost freebies considering what I shipped him vs. what he paid.
marmasatt was the Seller on October 13, 2019 AnandTech
Wow. This is a first for me. Not once have I given or rec'd a negative feedback in over 16 years of trading. Boy he earned this one. I've had a few days to cool off and I'm still leaving it. Where do I start. Communication was abysmal. We started this trade 8/13 and I shipped 10/13. Need I say more about that? He kept wanting to scour the internet to see if he could find things cheaper. I totally get it. But there comes a time that you just bite the bullet and say you're interested or not interested. I could see him logging on and off AT yet he would refuse to answer. Then he would respond, and ask me to give him a few more days and message him again. I called him out on it after the 3rd time or so and he said he had family in the hospital. I did too. So I chalked it up to being flighty and we still did the deal.
He told me to get all of this stuff ready and that he would pay for shipping. Then when push came to shove, he would NOT pay shipping. I was a bit peeved and I told him I went through all of this trouble scouring my stuff to get what he wanted and he obviously wants it and I'll get rid of it - so let's get a new deal going. Told him to pay me $3 shipping and I'd basically eat the rest. Well it costs $13 to ship and that was USPS ground. Deal was for $33 total for 2 10K SAS drives and 25 sticks of memory. Where I come from, these are almost freebies. A buck a stick for memory? Well shame on me and I shipped ground and apparently the box came pretty beat up. I did NOT realize that insurance was not included. My fault. So apparently alot of the air bags popped and the memory clanked together. Samir starts taking pictures of stuff and I don't know what I'm looking at. He's claiming that there were little solder dots in the bag (not ram chips mind you) so he narrowed it down to 1 HD and 3 sticks of ram. I wanted more info. I asked him to test the items. He now refused to test them because he doesn't want to damage his old systems. Before you know it, he files a claim with paypal and now wants a refund of $13 when he paid $20 for 25 sticks of ram and 2 hard drives! I was taken aback. I asked him repeatedly where he was getting this figure? Now he starts linking me to prices of the 4 damaged items which total more than $13.. I frankly told him "You refused to pay Ebay prices and said you needed a deal. So why would you now go to Ebay to look up replacement costs of various chips when your costs was a buck apiece?" He said that's how it should be done. I countered with the fact that if he buys a $500 laptop on sale for $300 and he buys it at $300 - and then goes to return it, he's not going to get $500 for the laptop, he should get what he paid. And if he does try to get more, he can be prosecuted in some states... (Just making my example.) So again, he paid a buck a stick. I offered him $8. He refused through pp. I apologized and offered him $10. He refused through paypal. Now I basically feel like he's extorting me for money when 3 sticks of ram out of 25 are bad. And that's "allegedly" because he refused to test! I didn't ask for the memory back and I acquiesced to his demands and refunded him $13. As I said, this was an absolute first for me. He definitely earned this one. I would be very cautious in dealing with him if he's that stubborn that he would refuse to ship back yet also refuse to test and just randomly extort you for some figures he found online that he believes is the value of the damaged items - when again..... he paid a buck a stick.
Response from SamirDSince I have an opportunity to reply, I'll do so.
Let's clarify on the exact inventory of the items--it was the following:
DDR2:
Samsung 2 x 512mgb pc2 5300
Samsung 2 x 2gb pc2 6400
1 Gb Nanya pc2 5300
Patriot 2 x 2gb Pc2 800mhz with heatspreaders
DDR:
Kingston 2 x 256 mb ddr 333
VData - 1 stick (either 512 or 1 gb) ddr 333
512 x 3 Hynix PC2 5300
1 Gb Hynix Pc2 5300
1 gig Transcend DDR2 800
1 Gb Nanya PC2 5300
2 x 2 Gig Nanya PC2 8400
2 Gb Hynix PC2 5300
DDR3: 2Gb Samsung PC3 10600
Also 2x 75gb 15k sas drives one in a Dell drive carrier
Yes, communication was abysmal. I usually interact quickly with someone who's interested. It didn't seem like the seller was really interested (as that does happen), so I didn't pursue it as a 'real' deal, especially when the seller didn't really move from what they wanted vs what I was willing to offer.
I never actually 'scoured the Internet to find things cheaper'. I know how much this stuff should cost and what a deal for me would look like.
As it did not seem like the seller was going to move on price to make this a deal for me, I didn't think there was a deal here. Only after he communicated to express his interest in a deal, did I basically lay down all my cards stating what is a deal for me and what is not. I also made an offer that he accepted--$33 shipped.
When I originally contacted him about this stuff I mentioned that I have a UPS account and can provide a prepaid label for shipping if that makes a deal easier. He seemed confused by this so I never really pursued it and in the end settled for a traditional transaction where the seller handles the shipping, which is almost always insured.
The packaging was severely inadequate for 2 3.5" sas drives and delicate memory in the same box. The drives were basically sitting on the floor of the box with the large air-bag style packing material, which in no way was going to wishstand the forces of these drives--and it didn't. The results was everything tumbling around in the box until it got to me. And the resulting carnage of ICs broken off memory modules and even the hard drive circuit board was not surprising. I haven't even tested anything else as of now as I don't want to be upset when it is all doa.
I found almost all the tiny ics that broke off and could figure out even where they came from, documented the damaged modules, and sent it to the seller expecting them to do a damage claim and then do a partial refund for the replacement value of the items. Sounded like a normal and fair thing to me, but apparently not to the seller.
And then I found out why--seller didn't get insurance so they're sol! Oh man! That sucks! I felt bad, but with $18 replacement cost of the stuff that's obviously physically broken (and saying nothing about the other stuff that may still be damaged), I felt that $13 was a fair refund. Seller didn't like this based on the 'price' I paid for the parts. I think that was irrelevant since the deal was for the parts to be in one piece in my hands, not for a bunch of scrap at a discounted ebay price.
I told the seller I could send everything back if he wanted to do a full refund. Seller refused. Seller insisted on me putting ic damaged items in working systems--I refused that as I'm not going to risk damaging my systems. We were at a stalemate so I brought in Paypal and Paypal helped resolve it.
Bottom line was that the seller messed up by not packaging or insuring the package and expected the buyer to eat with with no seller's remourse. To me that's unethical so I'm going to stand my ground on what I deem fair in that situation. If the tables were turned, I would have kicked myself for messing up and inconveniencing someone else who expected nice stuff.November 5, 2019
-
cbjzarace (30)
Geez, I haven\'t done this in 10 yrs of trading but this really ticked me off. Funny thing is, he doesn\'t seem like a bad guy, just kind of a kid who made a few bad choices. He posted an item. We agreed on a price. I then paid him. He says he\'ll ship. And then heeven provides me a tracking number that the item has shipped.
marmasatt was the Buyer on December 29, 2009 AnandTech
Later in the day Zach emails me and tells me the laptop is having problems. And that it specifically had like hardware issues (bad Hard drive). I got it at a pretty fair price, so I tell him, I\'ll take it anyway and just eat the cost of another Hard drive for $50. Now he still won\'t ship it? Why is that then? Either poor planning and putting something up for sale prematurely, or he got cold feet and decided otherwise (or sold it to someone else for all I know). I cannot recommend this guy. I\'m pretty darned ticked. I stopped looking for a lappy after we had a deal, and even bought a new battery for this model after we had a deal. And he still won\'t sell it to me...Now I have to return or sell this battery and continue to spend another month looking for a laptop..Proceed w/ caution.
Response from cbjzaraceI simply didn\'t feel comfortable selling a laptop that no longer fit the description of the sale; I decided I would rather keep a newly-broken laptop. Circumstances had changed, and I thought it within my rights to cancel the sale. The buyer was promptly and fully refunded--there was no deceit and no \"backdoor deals.\" I feel the buyer overreacted somewhat, considering the situation and the ultimate outcome.December 30, 2009
-
terrett101 (7)
Sold him a new Xbox 360 and a game.
marmasatt was the Seller on July 24, 2009 AnandTech
Ben\'s a good guy. He has indicated he\'s had a few trades already and has not rec\'d heat. I believe it. We were actually on neighboring states and did the deal face to face. Courteous, professional, and an all around nice guy. Would not hesitate to do business with him again.
July 25, 2009
-
milehigh (63)
Cross traded Ram New 2700 for 3200.
Cross-traded on August 15, 2004 AnandTech
Cross traded sticks of 512 Megs w/ Jeff. Great trader and a great guy. Well packaged and shipped quickly. A + trader.
August 15, 2004
-
LordOverLord (39)
Sold him an X-Dreamer Case
marmasatt was the Seller on June 14, 2006 AnandTech
Sold Mike a lightly used PC Case. Nice guy, shipped quickly. Would do business w/ him again for sure.
June 15, 2006
-
friarfraust (10)
Sold him a socket 754 mobo / 3300+ processor combo.
marmasatt was the Seller on June 2, 2008 AnandTech
Nice guy, was understanding about testing the mobo/cpu as I could not. We worked it out and I would not hesitate to do business with him again.
June 3, 2008
-
Taggerd (46)
Purchased a starter HTPC from Terry in exchange for cash and a few odds and ends.
Cross-traded on March 30, 2006 AnandTech
Similar to the previous poster, we avoided a situation that could have been disastrous with lesser civil traders. I was under the impression that the purchase price included an OS on the system. (Somehow after 20 PM\'s) we still got our lines crossed. We ended up basically splitting the difference and I ended up getting refunded some. The item was extremely well packed - among the best jobs I\'ve ever seen. Terry shipped quickly and kept in constant communication. I would not hesitate to do business with him again. A truly great deal and a great trade.
March 31, 2006
-
tacsplace (184)
Sold an Intel HSF to Todd
marmasatt was the Seller on March 2, 2006 AnandTech
Nice guy w/ with quick shipping. Would not hesitate to do business with him again.
March 3, 2006
-
mike2fix (757)
Purchased a great condition Iphone4 from Mike.
marmasatt was the Buyer on May 1, 2013 AnandTech
What a guy. His reputation precedes him. No muss, no fuss. Good price, good packaging, good communication. Thanks for the deal!
May 7, 2013
-
reg_pfj (43)
Sold Eric FC2 for PC
marmasatt was the Seller on June 8, 2009 AnandTech
Nice guy. Paid quickly w/ good communication. No problems here.
June 9, 2009
-
leftyman (46)
Sold him some Beatles Cd\'s
marmasatt was the Seller on January 20, 2006 AnandTech
Sold Tome a few Beatles CD\'s I wasn\'t listening to. Very good communication and quick shipping. Would not hesitate to do business w/ him again.
January 21, 2006
-
phife (252)
System Shock 2
marmasatt was the Seller on September 19, 2004 AnandTech
I sold Kevin SS2. No problems here. Kevin is a good guy and a good trader. Thanks.
September 19, 2004
-
JWade (467)
Sold Jeff some video cards, memory, processors.
marmasatt was the Seller on February 27, 2019 AnandTech
He bought a ton of stuff and is a great guy to do business with. Communication was great even though he was moving. Courteous and no nonsense. Hope we can do business again.
March 10, 2019
-
Screen (105)
Sold him $900 in Best Buy Gift Cards.
marmasatt was the Seller on December 26, 2011 AnandTech
Nice guy. No problems here. Would deal with him again. Thanks for the deal.January 6, 2012
-
sewerrat (26)
Bought a couple of nice phones for Sprint
marmasatt was the Buyer on May 6, 2007 AnandTech
Nice guy and great prices. Bought a two nice flip phones. He shipped quickly with great communication the whole time. And to boot, better price than I could have imagined. Thanks for the deal.
May 7, 2007
-
hottnucks (66)
GSkill DDR4 3200 memory 8GB x 2 (one stick defective)
marmasatt was the Seller on August 26, 2019 AnandTech
Paid fine. Could have communicated more, but seemed like a nice enough guy.
September 14, 2019
-
frostedflakes (184)
Sold Adam a PNY Flash Drive
marmasatt was the Seller on May 31, 2007 AnandTech
Nice guy. Stayed in constant communication. Thanks for the deal Adam.
June 1, 2007
-
Fenriss (447)
Sold Carl some HD-DVD\'s and PC Games
marmasatt was the Seller on November 30, 2008 AnandTech
Quick payment. Good communication here. Thanks for the deal!
December 1, 2008
-
gzervali2006 (174)
Purchased a Dell Latitude D400 Laptop from him.
marmasatt was the Buyer on February 28, 2011 AnandTech
Good guy, shipped quickly, and what a price! Thanks for the deal.
March 7, 2011
-
rstarr (55)
Purchased a 256 Meg stick of PC133
marmasatt was the Buyer on August 1, 2004 AnandTech
Rick is a stand up guy and no BS trader. Offered to cross ship w/ my inferior refs. Product came early and packaged the best it could have possibly been packaged. Thanks Rick. A+ trade.
August 1, 2004
-
Drozdov (221)
Bought Wolfenstein for PC from him.
marmasatt was the Buyer on September 11, 2009 AnandTech
Nice guy, shipped relatively quickly w/ good communication - and gave a great deal. Thanks, my man.
September 12, 2009
-
AMD Soldier (354)
OfficeMax Gift Cards
marmasatt was the Seller on May 22, 2004 AnandTech
Sold Alex some OM Gift Cards. Very smooth deal. Professional, Courteous trader w/ good communication. A+
May 22, 2004
-
Sniper82 (397)
Bought Max Payne 2
marmasatt was the Buyer on December 2, 2003 AnandTech
I bought Max Payne 2 from David. It was well packaged, perfect condition, and nice price. Seasoned veteran trader w/ good communication to boot. Thank you.
December 2, 2003
-
Wolfchild (411)
Sold 5 PC Games to him.
marmasatt was the Seller on January 12, 2004 AnandTech
Scott is a real veteran trader. Good communication and good guy. Has over 10 times more heat than I, and shipped first even though I didn't ask. Would deal with him again in a second.
January 12, 2004
-
Alex00 (443)
Traded Quake Wars: Enemy Territory for SOF:Payback.
Cross-traded on July 16, 2008 AnandTech
Nice fellow, easy to deal with. Item shipped the following day after discussion. Thanks for the deal.
July 17, 2008